Daniel Jones and the Surprising 4–1 Colts

Read Time:3 Minute, 18 Second

Indianapolis Finds Its Identity Behind a Revitalized Quarterback

When the Indianapolis Colts signed Daniel Jones this past offseason, most analysts scoffed. The move seemed like a temporary patch — a bridge to the future rather than a foundation for the present. But five weeks into the 2025 NFL season, the narrative has flipped.

The Colts are 4–1, sitting near the top of the AFC South, and Jones — once written off in New York — is suddenly playing the best football of his career.

A Fresh Start in the Circle City

For years, the Colts searched for stability under center. Since Andrew Luck’s retirement, they cycled through Philip Rivers, Carson Wentz, Matt Ryan, and even Gardner Minshew — flashes of competence, but no long-term answer.

Enter Daniel Jones.

After a frustrating and injury-filled stint with the Giants, Jones came to Indianapolis with little fanfare and a heavy chip on his shoulder. What he’s found under head coach Shane Steichen is freedom — both schematically and mentally.

“It’s just about playing fast and trusting what we see,” Jones said after the team’s Week 5 win. “Coach Steichen has simplified things for us and given me the confidence to go make plays.”

That confidence shows. Through five games, Jones has thrown for 1,225 yards, 10 touchdowns, and just 2 interceptions, while adding 186 rushing yards. He’s taking fewer sacks, spreading the ball around, and making decisive reads — something that eluded him in New York’s rigid offense.

Steichen’s Blueprint: Marrying Mobility with Precision

Shane Steichen, known for helping develop Jalen Hurts in Philadelphia, has tailored the Colts’ system to Jones’s strengths. The offense blends zone reads, quick play-action, and designed quarterback runs that maximize Jones’s athleticism.

Unlike in New York, Jones isn’t asked to be a statue in the pocket. He’s moving, improvising, and — perhaps most importantly — protecting himself better.

The presence of a balanced run game helps, too. Jonathan Taylor and Zack Moss have formed a powerful one-two punch, combining for nearly 600 yards and 6 touchdowns through Week 5.

That ground success has opened the passing lanes for Michael Pittman Jr., Josh Downs, and tight end Jelani Woods, each emerging as reliable weapons in an evolving attack.

A Defense That Complements the Offense

While Jones and the offense have grabbed headlines, the Colts’ defense has been quietly consistent. Led by DeForest Buckner and Zaire Franklin, the unit ranks among the top ten in takeaways and red-zone efficiency.

Rookie cornerback Kool-Aid McKinstry has also been a revelation, showing poise beyond his years and giving the secondary a reliable shutdown option.

It’s a group built on speed, discipline, and pressure — the perfect complement to an offense that’s built on rhythm and pace.

Redemption Story in Progress

Daniel Jones’s turnaround has been one of the early-season surprises. The quarterback once labeled as “overpaid” and “underperforming” now looks revitalized, comfortable, and quietly confident.

“You can feel the energy around this team,” said Pittman Jr. “There’s a belief in the locker room that we can beat anybody. DJ’s a big reason for that.”

Jones’s resurgence also underscores a larger point: sometimes, a player doesn’t need a miracle — just the right fit.

What’s Next for Indy

The schedule tightens ahead: matchups with the Texans, Bengals, and Bills will test whether the Colts are contenders or pretenders. But if the first five weeks are any indication, Indianapolis might finally have something sustainable.

Steichen’s vision is working. The roster is balanced. And Daniel Jones — once cast aside — might just be rewriting his story.

Bottom Line

The Colts were supposed to be rebuilding.
Daniel Jones was supposed to be forgotten.

Instead, both are thriving — together.
And if the 4–1 start is any indication, the rest of the AFC might want to start paying attention to the team in blue and white that nobody saw coming.