Betting on Breakouts: Colts Players Poised to Outperform in 2025

Read Time:3 Minute, 24 Second

As the Indianapolis Colts gear up for the 2025 NFL season, several players are positioned to exceed expectations. For bettors, identifying these potential breakout stars can provide valuable insights when placing strategic wagers.

Let’s dive into which players are poised for greatness.

Alec Pierce: Ascending Deep Threat

Alec Pierce, the wide receiver from the University of Cincinnati, had a career year in 2024 and is poised to elevate his performance further in 2025. Known for his prowess in stretching the field, Pierce benefited from quarterbacks willing to exploit his deep-threat capabilities. With continued development and chemistry with the Colts’ quarterbacks, Pierce could become a pivotal figure in the offense.

In fact, he’s already gaining attention in offseason reports and training camp coverage. For bettors looking to spot value before the market adjusts, keeping a close eye on NFL player news related to Pierce—especially target share, route usage, and depth chart movement—can offer early indicators of how involved he’ll be in the offense. Bettors might consider targeting over/under markets on receiving yards and touchdowns, anticipating his increased role in the Colts’ aerial attack.

Daniel Jones: Revival Under Center

Quarterback Daniel Jones, who joined the Colts on a one-year, $14 million deal, is anticipated to experience a career resurgence in 2025. Jones brings a blend of experience and athleticism to Indianapolis, and early projections suggest he could outperform expectations. For those placing bets, monitoring Jones’ performance in early-season games could offer opportunities in player prop markets, particularly in passing yards and touchdowns.

Kwity Paye: Defensive Disruptor

Defensive end Kwity Paye, entering his fifth season with the Colts, has shown steady improvement each year. In 2024, he recorded 8 sacks, underscoring his growing impact on the defensive line. As the Colts look to bolster their pass rush, Paye is expected to play a more prominent role.

Bettors might find value in wagering on team sack totals and defensive performance metrics, considering Paye’s potential to disrupt opposing offenses.

Jaylon Carlies: Versatile Defender

Drafted in the fifth round of the 2024 NFL Draft, Jaylon Carlies transitioned from safety to linebacker, showcasing his adaptability on defense. By the end of July 2024, Carlies had risen to third on the team’s linebacker depth chart, indicating the coaching staff’s confidence in his abilities. As he continues to acclimate to his new role, Carlies could emerge as a key contributor. Bettors should keep an eye on his tackle counts and potential for turnovers, which could influence defensive prop bets.

Impact of the 2025 NFL Draft

The Colts hold seven picks in the 2025 NFL Draft, scheduled for April 24-26 in Green Bay, Wisconsin. Their selections are:

Round 1: No. 14 overall
Round 2: No. 45
Round 3: No. 80
Round 4: No. 117
Round 5: No. 151
Round 6: No. 189
Round 7: No. 232

These picks give Indianapolis a chance to reinforce both sides of the ball, especially in areas that saw inconsistent play last season. Analysts have linked the team to potential early-round selections at tight end and cornerback—two positions that could immediately impact the starting roster.

For bettors, the draft isn’t just about future development—it directly influences expectations heading into the season. If the Colts land a starting-caliber offensive weapon or a lockdown defender, it could shift public perception and alter win totals, prop markets, and spreads. Those betting on the Indianapolis Colts odds will want to reassess projections shortly after draft weekend, especially if any of these rookies are expected to start in Week 1.

Strategic Betting Considerations

When evaluating the Colts’ potential breakout players, it’s essential for bettors to consider factors such as player health, team chemistry, and coaching strategies. Analyzing preseason performances and staying informed about training camp reports can provide valuable insights. Additionally, understanding how the Colts’ draft selections integrate into the team will be crucial for making informed wagers throughout the season.

By focusing on these emerging talents and the team’s strategic moves, bettors can position themselves to capitalize on the Colts’ potential upswing in the 2025 NFL season.